adllm Insights logo adllm Insights logo

Implementing Custom Memory Allocators in C++ for Game Engines Targeting WebAssembly

Published on by The adllm Team. Last modified: . Tags: c++ webassembly wasm gamedev memory-management emscripten performance memory-allocator

High-performance game engines demand precise control over memory management. While standard library allocators are convenient, they often fall short in meeting the stringent performance, predictability, and fragmentation requirements of complex games. This need for control is amplified when targeting WebAssembly (Wasm), where C++ game engines run within a browser environment, interacting with a unique linear memory model. Implementing custom memory allocators becomes a critical strategy for optimizing Wasm-based games.

This article explores the rationale, design patterns, and C++ implementation considerations for custom memory allocators in game engines compiled to WebAssembly using Emscripten. We’ll cover common allocator types, how they interact with Wasm’s linear memory and memory.grow, and best practices for achieving efficient memory usage.

Why Custom Allocators in a WebAssembly Context?

WebAssembly runs C++ code in a sandboxed environment with a linear memory, a large, contiguous ArrayBuffer that acts as the application’s heap. Memory is managed primarily through tools like Emscripten, which compiles C++ to Wasm and provides implementations of malloc/free and new/delete. Emscripten offers different underlying allocators, such as dlmalloc (the traditional default) and mimalloc (often faster, especially for multi-threaded applications, and a good modern default via -s MALLOC=mimalloc).

However, even with optimized general-purpose allocators like mimalloc, game engines often benefit from custom solutions for several reasons:

  1. Performance: Standard allocators can be slow for specific, frequent allocation patterns (e.g., many small, short-lived objects). Custom allocators can be tailored for these patterns.
  2. Fragmentation Control: Wasm’s single linear memory makes it susceptible to fragmentation. If free memory is broken into many small, non-contiguous blocks, allocations can fail even if enough total free memory exists. Custom allocators (like pool or arena allocators) can drastically reduce fragmentation for specific use cases.
  3. Predictability & memory.grow Management: The Wasm linear memory can be expanded using the memory.grow operation. This operation can be relatively slow and, in some older browser versions or specific circumstances, could even involve detaching and reattaching JavaScript views of the memory. Custom allocators can request larger chunks of memory from the system less frequently, then sub-allocate, minimizing calls to memory.grow.
  4. Memory Tracking & Debugging: Custom allocators allow for embedding detailed memory tracking, statistics, leak detection, and debugging aids (like memory guards) tailored to the engine’s needs.
  5. Exploiting Game-Specific Lifetimes: Games often have objects with well-defined lifetimes (e.g., per-frame, per-level). Allocators like stack/arena allocators are perfect for these scenarios.

Common Custom Allocator Types for Game Engines (and Wasm)

The principles of custom allocator design in C++ apply to Wasm, but their implementation must be mindful of the linear memory environment. Typically, a custom allocator will request a large block of memory from Emscripten’s malloc (or manage a pre-allocated segment of the Wasm heap if ALLOW_MEMORY_GROWTH=0) and then manage sub-allocations within that block.

1. Stack Allocator (Arena / Linear Allocator)

  • Concept: Allocates memory linearly from a pre-allocated buffer by simply bumping a pointer. Deallocation is typically done by resetting the pointer to a previous state, freeing all subsequent allocations at once.
  • Pros: Extremely fast allocations (pointer increment). No fragmentation within the arena for a given stack frame. Perfect for temporary, per-frame, or per-scope data.
  • Cons: Memory must be deallocated in LIFO (Last-In, First-Out) order. Not suitable for objects with interleaved lifetimes.
  • Wasm Context: Ideal for managing transient data within a game loop or loading stage. Helps keep temporary allocations out of the general-purpose allocator, reducing its fragmentation.
 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48

// Simplified Stack Allocator Example
class StackAllocator {
public:
    explicit StackAllocator(size_t size_bytes) {
        // In Wasm, this initial_buffer would typically be allocated
        // via Emscripten's malloc or be part of a larger static buffer.
        // For simplicity, using standard new here for the concept.
        start_ptr_ = new unsigned char[size_bytes];
        current_ptr_ = start_ptr_;
        total_size_ = size_bytes;
    }

    ~StackAllocator() {
        delete[] start_ptr_; // Release the block back to the underlying allocator
    }

    void* allocate(size_t bytes, size_t alignment = alignof(std::max_align_t)) {
        // Align current_ptr_ up
        void* aligned_ptr_raw = current_ptr_;
        if (std::align(alignment, bytes, aligned_ptr_raw, total_size_ - (current_ptr_ - start_ptr_))) {
             current_ptr_ = static_cast<unsigned char*>(aligned_ptr_raw) + bytes;
             return aligned_ptr_raw;
        }
        return nullptr; // Out of memory or alignment failed
    }

    // Marker for resetting the stack
    using Marker = unsigned char*;
    Marker getMarker() const { return current_ptr_; }

    void freeToMarker(Marker marker) {
        // Ensure marker is valid and within bounds
        if (marker >= start_ptr_ && marker <= start_ptr_ + total_size_) {
            current_ptr_ = marker;
        }
    }

    void clear() { current_ptr_ = start_ptr_; }

private:
    unsigned char* start_ptr_ = nullptr;
    unsigned char* current_ptr_ = nullptr;
    size_t total_size_ = 0;

    // Non-copyable
    StackAllocator(const StackAllocator&) = delete;
    StackAllocator& operator=(const StackAllocator&) = delete;
};

2. Pool Allocator (Fixed-Size Allocator)

  • Concept: Manages a collection of fixed-size memory blocks. When an object is allocated, a free block is taken from a list. When deallocated, it’s returned to the free list.
  • Pros: Very fast allocation/deallocation for objects of a known size. No internal fragmentation (as blocks are fixed size). Eliminates external fragmentation for objects managed by the pool.
  • Cons: Only suitable for objects of a single, predetermined size.
  • Wasm Context: Excellent for game entities, particles, bullets, or any frequently created/destroyed objects of the same class.
 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57

// Simplified Pool Allocator Example
template <typename T>
class PoolAllocator {
public:
    explicit PoolAllocator(size_t num_elements)
        : num_elements_(num_elements) {
        // In Wasm, memory_block_ would typically come from Emscripten's malloc
        // or a larger custom-managed region.
        block_size_ = sizeof(T);
        // Ensure alignment if T has specific requirements greater than a char
        if (alignof(T) > block_size_) block_size_ = alignof(T);

        memory_block_ = static_cast<unsigned char*>(
            ::operator new(num_elements_ * block_size_, std::align_val_t{alignof(T)})
        );

        free_list_head_ = memory_block_;
        unsigned char* current = memory_block_;
        for (size_t i = 0; i < num_elements_ - 1; ++i) {
            // Store next pointer in the block itself
            *reinterpret_cast<unsigned char**>(current) = current + block_size_;
            current += block_size_;
        }
        *reinterpret_cast<unsigned char**>(current) = nullptr; // Last block
    }

    ~PoolAllocator() {
        ::operator delete(memory_block_, std::align_val_t{alignof(T)});
    }

    T* allocate() {
        if (!free_list_head_) return nullptr; // Pool exhausted

        T* block = reinterpret_cast<T*>(free_list_head_);
        free_list_head_ = *reinterpret_cast<unsigned char**>(free_list_head_); // Advance free list
        // Note: Object is NOT constructed here, only memory is provided.
        // Use placement new.
        return block;
    }

    void deallocate(T* ptr) {
        if (!ptr) return;
        // Note: Object destructor should be called manually before this.
        *reinterpret_cast<unsigned char**>(ptr) = free_list_head_;
        free_list_head_ = reinterpret_cast<unsigned char*>(ptr);
    }

private:
    size_t num_elements_;
    size_t block_size_;
    unsigned char* memory_block_ = nullptr;
    unsigned char* free_list_head_ = nullptr; // Head of singly linked list of free blocks

    // Non-copyable
    PoolAllocator(const PoolAllocator&) = delete;
    PoolAllocator& operator=(const PoolAllocator&) = delete;
};

3. Overriding new/delete and STL Allocators

To integrate custom allocators seamlessly:

  • Class-Specific new/delete: Overload operator new and operator delete for specific classes to use a dedicated pool allocator.
 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15

class MyGameObject {
    // ... members ...
public:
    static PoolAllocator<MyGameObject> s_pool; // Assume initialized elsewhere

    static void* operator new(size_t size) {
        // Ensure size matches, though compiler usually guarantees this
        return s_pool.allocate();
    }
    static void operator delete(void* ptr) {
        s_pool.deallocate(static_cast<MyGameObject*>(ptr));
    }
    // ... constructor, destructor ...
};
// PoolAllocator<MyGameObject> MyGameObject::s_pool(1024); // Global instance
  • Placement new: Essential for constructing objects in memory obtained from a custom allocator. void* mem = my_stack_allocator.allocate(sizeof(MyObject)); MyObject* obj = new (mem) MyObject();
  • STL Allocators: Create allocator classes that conform to the C++ Standard Library’s allocator requirements. This allows std::vector, std::map, etc., to use your custom memory pools.
    1
2
3
4
5
6
7

    template <class T>
struct MySTLAllocator {
    typedef T value_type;
    // ... (constructor, destructor, allocate, deallocate, etc.) ...
    // Needs to use an underlying custom allocator (e.g., a global stack or pool)
};
// std::vector<MyData, MySTLAllocator<MyData>> my_custom_vector;

Interacting with Emscripten and Wasm Linear Memory

  • INITIAL_MEMORY and ALLOW_MEMORY_GROWTH: Emscripten linker flags are crucial.
    • -s INITIAL_MEMORY=<bytes>: Sets the initial size of the Wasm linear memory. Choose a reasonable starting size to avoid immediate memory.grow calls.
    • -s ALLOW_MEMORY_GROWTH=1 (default): Allows the heap to grow via memory.grow. If set to 0, the heap is fixed; malloc will return nullptr if it runs out of space.
  • The Cost of memory.grow: While modern browser engines optimize this, memory.grow can still be a noticeable pause, especially if it triggers a large increase or if the system is under memory pressure. Custom allocators that manage their own large regions can amortize this cost.
  • Memory Cannot Shrink: A key characteristic of Wasm’s linear memory is that it can grow, but there’s no mechanism to shrink it and return memory to the OS. This means the browser will continue to reserve the peak Wasm heap size, even if your custom allocators have freed much of it internally. This can lead to perceived high memory usage by users.
  • No sbrk or mmap: Custom allocators cannot directly use OS-level primitives like sbrk or mmap as they would on native platforms. All “system” memory comes from expanding the Wasm linear memory buffer.

Debugging and Profiling Custom Allocators in Wasm

Debugging memory issues in Wasm can be challenging.

  • Built-in Statistics: Embed counters and trackers in your allocators:
    • Number of active allocations.
    • Total memory used by each allocator.
    • Peak memory usage.
    • Number of times a pool runs out of blocks.
    • Fragmentation metrics (if applicable).
  • Memory Guards (Canaries): Write known byte patterns (e.g., 0xDEADBEEF) before and after allocated blocks. Check these on deallocation or periodically to detect buffer overflows/underflows.
  • Fill Freed Memory: When memory is deallocated, fill it with a distinct pattern to help identify use-after-free bugs (e.g., if you later find code reading this pattern).
  • Emscripten’s Sanitizers:
    • AddressSanitizer (-fsanitize=address): Can detect some memory errors but adds overhead. Its effectiveness for very custom allocator logic might vary.
  • Logging: In debug builds, log allocation/deallocation events (pointer, size, allocator type, source location using __FILE__/__LINE__). This can be very verbose but invaluable.
  • Browser Developer Tools:
    • Memory Tab: Useful for inspecting the total size of the WebAssembly.Memory ArrayBuffer. Some browsers offer heap snapshotting, but this primarily shows the JS heap and might only show the Wasm memory as a large opaque block.
    • Profiler: Can help identify if significant time is spent within your allocation/deallocation functions or in memory.grow.
    • Source Maps (-g4): Crucial for debugging C++ code in browser dev tools, allowing you to set breakpoints and inspect variables in your C++ source.

Best Practices and Considerations

  • Start Simple, Profile First: Don’t implement complex custom allocators prematurely. Use Emscripten’s default (mimalloc is a strong choice) and profile your application. Only introduce custom allocators if malloc/free or memory.grow show up as significant bottlenecks for specific patterns.
  • Alignment: Always ensure your allocators return memory aligned to the requirements of the data types being stored. std::align or manual pointer arithmetic can achieve this. alignof(std::max_align_t) is a good default alignment.
  • Thread Safety (for Wasm Threads): If using Wasm threads (pthreads support via Emscripten), your custom allocators must be thread-safe. This usually involves mutexes or more complex lock-free data structures, significantly increasing complexity. mimalloc is designed for multi-threading.
  • Error Handling: Decide how allocators should behave on out-of-memory conditions. Return nullptr? Throw std::bad_alloc? Abort?
  • Test Rigorously: Memory management code is notoriously prone to subtle bugs. Create extensive unit tests for your custom allocators.

Conclusion

Implementing custom memory allocators in C++ for WebAssembly-targeted game engines is an advanced optimization technique that can yield significant performance and stability improvements. By understanding Wasm’s linear memory model, the behavior of memory.grow, and Emscripten’s role, developers can design allocators like stack and pool allocators to manage memory efficiently, reduce fragmentation, and gain finer control over their engine’s resource footprint. While the default allocators provided by Emscripten (especially mimalloc) are highly capable, custom solutions offer the ultimate control for specific, demanding workloads, ensuring that browser-based games can achieve the performance and predictability users expect. Always profile carefully to justify the added complexity, and leverage Emscripten’s debugging tools and source maps to navigate the challenges of Wasm development.